Explainer: Understanding the BRICS Currency Proposal and Its Feasibility

Introduction

Recent discussions at the BRICS summit in Johannesburg have sparked interest in the idea of a common currency for trade and investment among the member nations – Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa. Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva proposed the idea as a means of reducing vulnerability to fluctuations in the dollar exchange rate. This article aims to shed light on the concept of a BRICS currency and explores the opinions of various leaders on the matter.

Lula’s Motivation for a BRICS Currency

President Lula prioritizes the freedom for nations not using the dollar to trade in their desired currencies. He has also advocated for a common currency within the South American Mercosur bloc. Lula believes that implementing a BRICS currency would expand payment options and reduce vulnerabilities faced by member nations.

Perspectives of Other BRICS Leaders

While South African officials initially stated that a BRICS currency was not on the summit agenda, President Cyril Ramaphosa’s government seemed open to discussion on boosting trade in national currencies. Indian officials echoed a similar sentiment, stating that the idea of a BRICS currency was not currently being considered. Russian President Vladimir Putin, attending the summit via videolink, expressed interest in exploring alternatives to the dollar for trade within the member countries. China, however, has not commented on the proposal, although President Xi Jinping emphasized the need to reform the international financial and monetary system.

Challenges in Establishing a BRICS Currency

Developing a BRICS currency would involve complex political, economic, and geographical considerations. South African central bank governor Lesetja Kganyago warned that establishing a BRICS currency would require a banking union, fiscal union, macroeconomic convergence, and a disciplining mechanism for member countries. Additionally, a common central bank would need to be established, raising questions about its location. Trade imbalances among the member nations pose another challenge, as most BRICS countries have China as their primary trading partner, with limited trade amongst themselves.

Assessing the Role of the U.S. Dollar

BRICS leaders have expressed their intentions to rely less on the U.S. dollar, as its strength fluctuates due to factors such as Federal Reserve interest rate hikes and geopolitical tensions. The sanctions-induced isolation of Russia from global financial systems further fueled speculation about a move away from the dollar by non-western allies. While the share of the U.S. dollar in official reserves has decreased, it remains dominant in global trade, being involved in nearly 90% of global forex transactions.

Conclusion

The proposition of a BRICS currency has stirred discussions among leaders, raising questions about its feasibility and potential benefits. While its implementation involves significant challenges such as political and economic alignment, trade disparities, and currency dominance, the idea has sparked interest in reducing reliance on the U.S. dollar. Only time will reveal whether the BRICS nations can find common ground and overcome these obstacles to establish a new currency for their trade and investment.

BRICS Expansion Impeded by Divisions, Threatening Global South’s Clout